Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Making a Bad System Worse

There were several references to increasing the minimum wage at the Democratic Presidential debate last night. I would like to address the statement by Bill Richardson, who said that the United States Congress must pass a minimum wage of forty thousand dollars per year for ALL public school teachers. Though I believe the current system fails to adequately compensate educators, Richardson's proposal is economically irresponsible. Many of the arguments against a general minimum wage also apply to raising the minimum wage for public school teachers. Instituting fixed pay for teachers is not the proper economic means to ensure a well-educated studentry.

In some states, educators are now paid based upon their ability and tenure. Promotions and higher pay result when teachers ensure that their students are excelling in the classroom. Instituting a minimum wage would, in essence, do little to ensure that quality teachers are rewarded and recruited. In fact, Bill Richardson's proposal would result in students receiving a poorer education. Some teachers would receive significantly higher compensation from the government regardless of how their students perform on standardized tests or other educational benchmarks. The average teacher's salary is already higher than the minimum wage proposed by Richardson. According to USA Today, the average teacher earns over forty-six thousand dollars per year. In other words, the youngest, least experienced, and worst quality teachers will be disproportionately benefited as a result of such legislation. A guaranteed wage would also stifle the drive to work harder and develop new teaching techniques which will benefit students. A minimum teaching wage lowers the incentives for educators to increase their own knowledge and skills. If a teacher is confronted with a choice between thirty-five thousand dollars a year with no master's degree or forty-five thousand dollars a year with one, it would obviously pay for the teacher to pursue a master's degree. When that choice is between forty thousand dollars a year without a master's degree or forty-five thousand dollars a year with one, the impetus for improving one's skills declines significantly (since there is less reward). Simply put, the quality of teaching will decline precipitously after the introduction of a minimum wage for teachers.

In the free market, increasing the minimum wage significantly would result in greater unemployment, since businesses would take fewer risks in hiring new employees because they must pay them an artificially high wage. In addition, any employee whose productivity does not compensate his employer for the wage he earns will be fired. With our education system, however, the results will be quite different. Since teachers receive their compensation directly from the taxpayer, four possibilities emerge. The first, and most likely result, is that more students will be placed in each classroom to lessen the burden on the taxpayer. Rather than having thirty students in a class, forty may be placed in a single classroom to offset the increased wages given to teachers. Teachers will get more money as a result, but the quality of education will undoubtedly decrease as students receive less personal attention from a teacher. However, this will be a viable solution for school districts if the budget remains static after a minimum wage for teachers is implemented. This also would allow the same number of teachers to remain employed.

The second possibility is an increase in taxes. Keeping classroom size and quality identical under this new policy would require a significant tax increase. As a result, millions of dollars will be taken from the taxpayers and redirected to public school teachers. If educational quality was improved dramatically, these added taxes might be worthwhile. However, as we are continuing to see, educational quality actually decreases with Richardson's proposal. Though such a tax increase is a distinct possibility, the third or fourth possibilities are more likely to occur.

A teacher's minimum wage might also cause capital to be substituted where it would otherwise be less efficient to do so. For instance, computers may be given to every student in order to facilitate learning, even though it would be more efficient for teachers to merely teach. If this occurs, our resources paid into the system as taxpayers will be used less efficiently. What happens when resources are not used most efficiently? The economy as a whole suffers and the standard of living is decreased.

Finally, the most skilled and experienced educators will likely receive a pay decrease as a result of the new minimum wage. In order to offset the pay increases for those who are currently making less than minimum wage without increasing taxes, class size, or substituting capital, the best teachers will fall victim to wage reductions. These same teachers might now look to private schools or other employment opportunities rather than endure a pay cut (or, at the very least, stagnant wages). Even if current class sizes are maintained and the taxpayer is placated, the educational quality of our public schools will be drastically harmed as the best teachers leave the public schools in droves. Ultimately, while New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson's idea may seem like the panacea our education system desperately needs, his proposal will only move our school systems further down the road of quality deterioration.

43 comments:

Elizabeth said...

Most insightful and enlightening.


[keep it up, eh?]

Elizabeth said...

your wish is my command.

*voila!*

Elizabeth said...

two posts in one month.

alert the media.

8541 said...

百發百中不是一試就成的。 ..................................................

pink said...

Unable to give you a heart. so have a reply to push up your post. ........................................

撒謊 said...

青春一逝不復返,事業一失難有成。 ..................................................

仲亨仲亨 said...

good~ keep sharing with us, please....I will waiting your up date everyday!! Have a nice day........................................

佩昭彥怡 said...

笑口常開~~天天開心........................................

政倫政倫 said...

路過--你好嗎..很棒的BLOG.........................................

鍾FeR_Quade0426 said...

wonderful...................................................

勝傑懿綺 said...

到處逛逛~~來繞繞留個言囉~~~~ .........................................

怡均 said...

今天是人生唯一生存的時間。......................................................

淑娟 said...

It's great!!..........................................

韋于倫成 said...

廢話不多,祝你順心~^^ ........................................

NealVa憲妤 said...

線上免費成人觀賞 視訊 摸摸耳聊天 免費av 視訊交友網 女優 性感寶貝 成人影片交流 偷拍性交 ut色情聊天室 女人愛愛 情趣 同志18禁 少女裸睡 aa洪爺影城 a片面 情色守門員 麗的色情小戲 一夜情 383影音live秀 影音視訊 玩美女人試看 美女女優寫真 辣妹自拍貼圖網 人妻線上看 免費影片 77p2p 85街 a圖網a圖貼圖 美女寫真 85cc+ 免費成人 85st 視訊聊天 貼圖區 援交 情人視訊 免費脫衣秀 dvd av女優 洪爺影城下載區 大奶影片 sex888貼圖區 170部a下載 日本巨乳a片 百性線上直播網 後宮電影院長 限制級視訊 0204視訊美女 免費性愛片 正妹日報

517SeritaG_Jamar0 said...

免費看成人影片 免費視訊聊天室 聊天 免費色情漫畫 免費交友 女優色情片 性感 免費影片 辣妹自拍 成人聊天室 愛愛 情趣 18成人線上影片 少女做愛圖 85cc成人 免費a片 情色成人圖 色情片試看 一夜情 383 影音視訊 玩美女人影音秀 自拍美女 性`愛辣妹 人妻自拍貼圖區 做愛影片 a片下載 視訊聊天 a圖貼片站 正妹寫真 85cc免費無碼片 免費視訊 嘟嘟 85cc 歐美貼圖 援交 情人視訊 鋼管秀 avooo 洪爺情色聊天 大奶辣妹 sex520 下載免費a片 日本巨乳 拓網交友 後宮電影院主入口 限制級 0204電話聊天 美國性愛 走光寫真

清民 said...

愛情不是慈善事業,不能隨便施捨。......................................................

筠銘 said...

待人要誠心,做事要用心,勝負平常心。......................................................

vickiekurt said...

xh美色網 免費a片下載嘟嘟情人色網影片 av,sex520免費影片 完全免費視訊聊天 777美女dvd辣妹視訊 免費視訊celia aio交友視訊愛情館 西門慶成人論壇 台中酒店S援交 sex888影片分享區高中生援交 一葉情貼影片區 1314視訊 情人線上aa片試看嘟嘟 情人視訊網a 妹妹視訊 情色網成人電影 xxxholic次元魔女 成人文學小弟弟貼影片區 亞亞成人館 ut成人聊天室 微風成人 go2av免費看影片 104黑色會美眉自慰 日本同志色教館情色文學成人小說 34c視訊辣妹美女sex888免費電影 情色視訊論壇 0204貼圖區免費色情電影 成人貼圖站 交友ggo 免費影片下載a gogo2sex日本 拓網交友視訊美女 080情人網伊利論壇 一本道 a片 東京熱免費成人影片觀賞 交友ggoo 夜未眠影片中心 34c情人視訊網 一夜情性 情色視訊 美女 亞洲禁果名模影城 日本av論壇 台南視訊34c美女館 bt論壇交友網成人情色視訊妹 免費情人視訊 性愛電影85cc 聊天室交友whei 38girl視訊美女 aa免費影片 獨秀視訊聊天室 av730美眉共國 辣妹哈啦聊天室

佳皓 said...

要持續更新下去喲!!祝你心情愉快.............................................................

夏瓊富 said...

看看文章轉換心情,也幫你加個油哦

陳芳 said...

幸福不是一切,人還有責任。.................................................................                           

亦妮亦妮 said...

人不能像動物一樣活著,而應該追求知識和美德.................................................................

美方 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

雅莊王edgd春2蕙婷余惠其 said...

如果成為一支火柴,也要點亮一個短暫的宇宙;如果是一隻烏鴉,也要叫疼閉塞的耳膜。.................................................................

香昱信張君林 said...

Thank you very much for such useful informaion ● 3●..................................................................

玉苓玉苓 said...

安安唷~~幸運的日子送給妳(你)滿滿的幸福,也祝福你天天都開心唷..................................................................

1986/6/7 said...

累了嗎?來杯咖啡休息一下吧!............................................................

于倫 said...

我真心在追求我的夢想時,每一天都是繽紛的。因為我知道每一個小時都是實現理想 的一部份。..................................................

淑慧淑慧 said...

you got it!i like it!!!............................................................

楊儀卉 said...

教育的目的,不在應該思考什麼,而是教吾人怎樣思考............................................................

魏江伶魏江伶 said...

死亡是悲哀的,但活得不快樂更悲哀。. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

魏智偉魏智偉 said...

永遠不要躊躇伸出你的手。也永遠不要躊躇接受別人伸出的手。.................................................................

許志蘇昶哲宏 said...

未來屬於那些相信他們美好夢想的人。......................................................

淑倫惟芳 said...

Poverty tries friends...................................................................

家唐銘 said...

凡事三思而行,跑得太快是會滑倒的。..................................................

王辛江淑萍康 said...

所有的資產,在不被諒解時,都成了負債.................................................................

子怡谷怡谷怡谷翔 said...

祝大家都平平安安健健康康!............................................................

忠姜姜姜蓮 said...

從人生中拿走友誼,猶如從生活中移走陽光......................................................................

怡禹玄禹玄君 said...

單純喜歡你的部落格 留個言跟您問聲好~~...............................................................

璇陳陳陳竹 said...

讓好心情回味發酵;壞心情留在文字裡隨時間消逝吧!............................................................

蕾蕾 said...

寂寞又無聊 看到你的BLOG 加油喔!!..................................................

偉DimpleHolloway043昀 said...

看著你的BLOG 好多朋友都回應 真厲害..................................................